“Good morning, Tony” — Between cultural ‘arrogance’ & corporate dissonance

“Good morning, Tony” — Between cultural ‘arrogance’ & corporate dissonance

“Don’t call me Tony”

Nigeria — one day, one major sweeping story.

This time, it’s with one of the country’s wealthiest men and finest businessmen, Tony Elumelu.

A seasoned banker and a significant contributor to the Nigerian financial ecosystem, Elumelu represents a seismic presence before most Nigerians.

He hosts an all-white party every year, inviting different classes of people. As with every man of his social status, access to him isn’t a given. He’s big fish.

That must have been the feeling of the young lady who stood up to ask him a question at the graduation ceremony for the trainees of Elumelu’s bank, United Bank for Africa.

For those young men and women, they were watching greatness, a legend in their industry, and a man whose ideas and efforts were about to become a major part of their stories.

When you’re in such a moment, it’s natural to be excited. You want to show off. For a young person, it’s natural to want to display how much information they’ve soaked up, leave an impression and be easily recalled.

If that was the intent of that young lady, maybe her wishes came true.

But perhaps for the wrong reasons.

“Good morning, Tony,” she said nasally before many other young people, all impending staff of UBA, and their bosses, who are also practically Elumelu’s staff.

“Haha. Good morning, Toyin,” Elumelu responded, as if the girl had mispronounced his name, or perhaps unsure of what she had said.

Audacity is a powerful material for successful people. If that lady is talented and knows her onions, she probably has what it takes to thrive in the ruthless world of the corporate industry.

Boldness, confidence and audacity are important tools to hold.

“I said ‘good morning, Tony,’” she said.

Someone must have said “ha ha” beside, behind or adjacent to her. She was bold in the moment, but Elumelu, surprised yet not nonplussed by the situation, was clear in his reaction.

“No, you won’t call me Tony. You call me TOE or Mr. Elumelu,” he said.

It was direct and straightforward.

Whatever question the lady followed with after she re-addressed Elumelu barely matters to the public.

The pile-on has been loud. Her supporters have also been vehement in their defence. Feminists have tagged it a patriarchal response. Different schools of thought have emerged.

But there’s a little to unpack.

Names are important in Nigeria’s social culture. Age, level and status determine what you call whoever you call. It’s one of the overriding principles of the society.

Hierarchy is clear, and names are significant in that respect.

But there’s also an infiltration of modernity and Westernisation in workplaces. First names have become a standard means of identification, probably against what many would have preferred. UBA holds that policy too, and indeed, so do most parts of the Nigerian financial sector.

Socially, it can be disrespectful to call an elderly person by their name. Culturally, it is often considered rude.

But in corporate establishments, there’s nothing inherently wrong with it.

That is the defence put up for the young lady.

And that defence is not entirely wrong.

But there is a difference between knowing a rule and knowing when the rule applies.

Until today, Elumelu was the chairman of UBA, and would probably not be in the policy mix applied by the lady.

What the lady lacked was perhaps not confidence, but discretion. What she had was a training she kept to, perhaps too deeply and without enough tact.

This is where the story becomes more interesting than a simple argument about respect.

Elumelu represents the corporation, but he is also an individual shaped by the same Nigerian social culture that exists outside the corporation. The workplace may encourage first-name familiarity, but social hierarchy does not simply disappear because someone walks into a corporate building.

That is the corporate dissonance.

The institution can teach you one rule, while the society around you teaches you another. And sometimes, the wisdom is knowing which one to apply.

Critics of Elumelu have said his action could lead to a policy dissonance. Perhaps.

But what that lady has learned from that short situation, and from the subsequent loudness of the widespread reaction to it, is that understanding the rules that guide one’s society can sometimes matter as much as understanding the rules of the institution you work for.

She may have learned that rules have exceptions.

She may have learned that hierarchy exists, even in places that preach informality.

And she may have learned that confidence without discretion can sometimes work against you.

Wisdom, after all, is not simply knowing what to do. It is knowing when to do it, how to do it and with whom.

Places are meant for humans, and humans are complicated.

She may well go to the greatest heights of her career. As she progresses, that incident may make more sense to her: the importance of wisdom, preparation and depth before application.

She’ll learn.

It happens to the best of us.

Originally published on Wolf of Words Street.